Discussion about this post

User's avatar
A. Palmer's avatar

This is a very confronting piece. Thank you for holding up a mirror to us all.

What struck me most was what you said about social isolation. If so many of our interactions our being replaced by AI, how does this affect this children, sick people and the elderly? I worry about the most vulnerable among us.

Dr. Martha Umana's avatar

Lisa, this is a wonderfully clear walk-through of the three factors. A commenter below asked what this means for children; that question is where I live professionally. Reading it from the child-development side, one line stayed with me: “we rationally know that the object is not human.” That rational anchor is something adults bring to the interaction. Young children are still building it; working out which things have minds and feelings is part of their development, and it takes years. So when a product is deliberately designed to activate our social responses, I keep wondering what that same design means for someone whose distinction between “feels human” and “is human” is still under construction. Your closing advice, keeping how a tool makes us feel separate from how reliable it is, may be something adults need to hold on children’s behalf for quite a while.

I am looking forward to the rest of the series.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?